By the MassBid Estimation team · Reviewed by a senior estimator with 10+ years of experience · Published · Updated
In short
We read the notes our estimators wrote on 74 recently delivered takeoffs and estimates. 43 percent of the bid sets were missing information the estimate depended on, 23 percent had a conflict between sheets, schedules or specifications, and 14 percent were missing whole sheets or drawing sets. In all, 55 percent had at least one gap or conflict the estimator had to resolve and write down. 31 percent needed an exclusion or scope split stated, and 18 percent turned out to have no new work in the trade being bid.
- Jobs studied
- 74 delivered takeoffs and estimates, about 200 written notes
- Missing information
- 32 jobs (43%)
- Conflict between documents
- 17 jobs (23%)
- Whole sheets or sets missing
- 10 jobs (14%)
- At least one gap or conflict
- 41 jobs (55%)
- Exclusion or scope split stated
- 23 jobs (31%)
- No new work in the trade
- 13 jobs (18%)
How the study was done
Every takeoff and estimate we deliver includes written notes: what was assumed, what was left out and where the documents disagree. We collected the notes files from the delivered jobs in our sample library and shared drives, removed duplicates and revisions of the same job, and left out architects' and engineers' notes copied from the drawings, so that only our estimators' own notes were counted.
That left 74 jobs and about 200 notes, across glazing and storefront, building envelope supplier takeoffs, flooring, residential framing, millwork, painting and structural connectors. Each job was then read and classified by hand. A job counts once in a category however many notes it has there, and a job can be in several categories.
The results: how often bid sets had problems
| Finding | Jobs | Share | Real example, names removed |
|---|---|---|---|
| Missing information the estimate depended on | 32 | 43% | No detail for the pad footing reinforcement; (4) #5 vertical bars with #3 ties at 6" o.c. assumed. |
| An exclusion or scope split had to be stated | 23 | 31% | Only aluminum doors are covered; hollow metal and wood doors are excluded. |
| The client was asked to confirm something | 20 | 27% | Frames may be part of another contractor. Kindly confirm and inform us. |
| Conflict between sheets, schedules or specifications | 17 | 23% | On the plan the spandrel glass is tagged IG-2, while on the elevation it is IG-3. |
| No new work in the trade being bid | 13 | 18% | Interior upfit: all storefronts are existing and new interior doors are solid core wood. |
| Whole sheets or drawing sets missing | 10 | 14% | A6.1 (door schedule and hardware) and A6.1.1 (window types) missing from the set. |
| A rule the client gave us was applied | 9 | 12% | Per the client's rule, no glass lite was priced below 4 sq ft. |
| An addendum or revision changed quantities | 4 | 5% | Addendum 2: polished concrete not in contract; clear sealer provided instead. |
| At least one gap or conflict | 41 | 55% | Missing information, a conflict, or both. |
The headline is simple: more than half of the bid sets we were sent could not be priced from the documents alone without a stated decision by the estimator. None of these are unusual projects. They are retail stores, restaurants, schools, apartments, a hotel and single-family homes.
Where the documents disagreed
The 17 jobs with conflicts had 19 of them. The most common was the plan disagreeing with the elevation, and the estimator usually followed the more detailed sheet and said so.
| Conflict | Jobs | Example, and how it was priced |
|---|---|---|
| Plan vs elevation | 6 | Many balcony windows on the elevation, few on the plan: the elevations were followed. |
| Drawings vs specification, notes or responsibility matrix | 4 | Glazed windows on the drawings, wood windows in the specification: both flagged with pictures for the client to verify. |
| Detail vs detail, or sheet vs sheet | 3 | One section shows metal flashing at the window head over brick, another shows none: the detailed section was used. |
| Demolition drawings vs new work | 2 | The demolition plan removes the vestibule; the notes keep its door system. |
| Schedule vs elevation | 2 | The door schedule says hollow metal; the elevation shows an aluminum storefront door with glass. |
| Duplicate tags or a wrong scale | 2 | One frame tag used for two different frames on the same sheet; the architectural scale was wrong. |
A conflict is a price question as well as a design one. Metal or shingle roof, hollow metal or aluminum door: each answer is a different number. The safe practice is to price one reading, say which, and send the question as an RFI before bid day.
What was missing, and what was assumed in its place
Missing information fell into two groups: whole documents that were never sent, and details that were never drawn.
| Missing | Jobs |
|---|---|
| The entire architectural set (only MEP or civil sheets were sent) | 3 |
| Specific sheets: plans, elevations, door or window schedules, an assembly sheet | 4 |
| The MEP drawings | 1 |
| The project specification manual | 1 |
| A referenced geotechnical report | 1 |
Where a detail was simply not drawn, the same assumptions came up again and again:
- Sill sealer width matched to the wall: 5.5" at 6" walls and 3.5" at 4" walls, where the type was not specified.
- Water heater supports and hardware per unit, priced from the client's own takeoff example and RFI response, on five multi-unit residential projects.
- A housewrap assumed where no weather-resistive barrier was named.
- Flashing at brick openings taken from a similar project by the same designer, where the enlarged sections were missing.
- Wall assemblies of 2x6 exterior and 2x4 interior, where the wall tags were not on the plans.
Every one of these was written down as an assumption, so the contractor could accept it, change it or ask the designer. An assumption that is not written down is a risk nobody knows they are carrying.
The most common exclusions and scope splits
| Excluded or split | Jobs | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Automatic sliding entrance doors | 8 | Often supplied by a specialty door manufacturer; excluded or flagged on storefront jobs. |
| Doors belonging to the door contractor | 5 | Hollow metal, wood and detention doors split from aluminum storefront doors. |
| Owner- or tenant-furnished items | 4 | Brand-procured furniture, tenant doors and windows, a national-account flooring system. |
| Flashing and coping by the roofing contractor | 2 | Parapet coping and drip edge left to the roofer. |
Exclusions protect both sides. A storefront bid that silently includes an automatic door is high; one that silently leaves it out is a change order waiting to happen. Stating it puts the decision with the contractor.
18% of bid invitations had no work in the trade
Thirteen jobs, mostly storefront invitations, turned out to have no new work in the trade once the drawings were read: interior upfits with existing storefronts, park and site projects, a salt storage building with no windows. A note saying so, sent before anyone spent a day on it, is worth as much as a takeoff. Our glazing estimating page shows notes from the jobs that did.
A pre-bid checklist from these findings
- Check the sheet index against the sheets you were sent before measuring anything.
- Compare the plan, the elevations and the schedules for every opening and finish tag you price.
- Read the general notes and the responsibility matrix for owner-furnished and by-others items.
- Check the demolition drawings against the new work on any renovation.
- Confirm every addendum is in the set, and what each one changed.
- Write down each assumption and exclusion, and send the open questions as RFIs before bid day.
How notes ship with our estimates
Every MassBid takeoff and estimate ships with notes like these, quoted against the drawing that caused them. You can see real notes by trade on the millwork, glazing, painting and GC estimating pages, read how we estimate, or send the drawings for a free quote.
Common questions
Very. In 74 bid sets we delivered estimates for, 55 percent had at least one gap or conflict the estimator had to resolve: 43 percent were missing information the estimate depended on and 23 percent had a conflict between sheets, schedules or specifications.
In our study, the plan disagreeing with the elevation was the most common, followed by the drawings disagreeing with the specification, notes or responsibility matrix, and one detail disagreeing with another.
Price one reading, state which one in the estimate, and send the question as an RFI before bid day. A conflict changes the price, so it should never be resolved silently.
Work that no contractor has priced because each assumed someone else had it, such as an automatic entrance door left out of both the storefront and the door bids. Stating exclusions and scope splits in writing is how scope gaps are prevented.
Items shown on the drawings but not priced, and why: owner- or tenant-furnished items, work by other trades, alternates, and anything without enough information to price. In our study, automatic entrance doors were the most common exclusion on storefront jobs.
In our study, 14 percent of bid sets were missing whole sheets or drawing sets, including three where the entire architectural set was missing.
