Skip to main content

Guide

How to choose a construction estimating company: 12 questions to ask before you hire one

Twelve questions to ask any estimating service before you hire it, what a good answer looks like, and the red flags to walk away from.

By the MassBid Estimation team · Reviewed by a senior estimator with 10+ years of experience · Published · Updated

In short

Before hiring a construction estimating company, ask who measures your job and how experienced they are in your trade, how the work is checked, how prices are set for your location, what you receive and in what format, how assumptions and exclusions are reported, how fast it is, and what revisions cost. A good company answers each one specifically and shows a real sample in your trade. Vague answers, no sample, no written assumptions and paid revisions are the red flags.

Most important question
Who measures my job, and do they work in my trade?
Ask to see
A real sample in your trade, with marked-up plans
Insist on
Written assumptions and exclusions
File format
An editable workbook with formulas, not just a PDF
Biggest red flag
No sample, or no notes on what was assumed

The 12 questions, and what a good answer sounds like

Questions to ask a construction estimating company and what a good answer looks like
QuestionA good answerOur answer
1. Who measures my project?In-house estimators, named by trade, not passed to unknown freelancers.More than 20 in-house estimators, each working in their trade.
2. How experienced are they in my trade?Years in the trade, and examples of similar jobs.Typically 7 to 10 years; samples by trade on request.
3. How is the work checked?A separate reviewer, not the person who did it.Two QA reviews by a separate team: quantities, then pricing.
4. Can I see a sample in my trade?A real delivered estimate, with client details removed.Yes, on the samples page and by request.
5. Where do the prices come from?Current prices for the project's location, not a national average.Our own vendor pricing database, by the project's ZIP code.
6. Can you use my rates and format?Yes: wage rates, production rates, markups and bid form.Yes. Every estimate is built to the client's specification.
7. What will I receive?An editable workbook and marked-up plans showing where each quantity came from.An editable Excel workbook with formulas, and marked-up plans.
8. How are assumptions and exclusions reported?In writing, against the drawing that caused them.Written notes with every package.
9. How fast is it?A quote within hours and a stated delivery date.Quote in about 20 minutes; estimates typically in 24 to 48 hours.
10. What do revisions and addenda cost?Included, with a stated turnaround.Free, no limit and no time limit; usually back within hours.
11. How is it priced?A fixed quote per project before work starts.A free quote per project; monthly plans for regular bidders.
12. What happens if a quantity is wrong?It is corrected at no charge.Corrected at no charge.
Our answers describe MassBid Estimation. Ask every company you are considering the same questions and compare the answers line by line.

Red flags

  • No real sample in your trade, or only a generic template.
  • Quantities with no marked-up plans to show where they came from.
  • No written assumptions or exclusions: the gaps are still there, just hidden.
  • A PDF only, with no editable workbook to change your markups.
  • Revisions and addenda charged extra, or limited to a short window.
  • A price per square foot of building with no takeoff behind it.
  • Vague answers about who does the work.

How to test a company before committing

  • Send one live bid you are also estimating yourself, and compare the quantities line by line.
  • Read the notes: did they catch the gaps and conflicts you found, or more?
  • Change a markup in the workbook and check that the totals follow.
  • Send an addendum and time the revision.

In our own study of 74 bid sets, more than half had a gap or conflict the estimator had to resolve, which is why question 8 matters. See what 74 real bid sets got wrong, or compare a service with an in-house estimator in estimating service vs in-house vs software.

Common questions

Ask who measures your job and their experience in your trade, how the work is checked, where prices come from, what you receive, how assumptions and exclusions are reported, how fast it is, and what revisions cost. Then test it on one live bid you are also estimating yourself.

Quantities by trade with marked-up plans, pricing for the project's location, an editable workbook with your markups, and written notes on assumptions, exclusions and drawing conflicts.

No real sample in your trade, no marked-up plans, no written assumptions or exclusions, PDF-only delivery, paid revisions, and vague answers about who does the work.

Send one live bid you are also estimating yourself, compare the quantities line by line, read the notes on what was assumed, and time a revision for an addendum.

Send your plans, get an exact price

Free quote in about 20 minutes. Estimates typically in 24 to 48 hours, with free revisions.